Originally Posted by ChefChiTown View Post
Have you ever been inside of a Federal Building? Have you ever been behind closed doors in a securely guarded government office? Have you ever talked to the people who work for the government, that are responsible for keeping our country safe? Have you ever actually seen what they do on a daily basis, just to keep you safe? Seriously, have you?
Ok, I'll bite.
I worked in the DC-Baltimore area from '95-'98 and again from '00-'02. Yes, I have been in "securely guarded government office"(s) before, but nothing that involves special security clearance (complete with elaborate background checks and so on). I have been inside, well, more federal buildings (there's no need to capitalize federal, btw) than I can actually count from memory. While neither of my parents works in government, I have numerous friends who do, and I can think of 3 who work within agencies within DHS, 2 of them in matters of substance.
One for this dept.:
http://www.dhs.gov/xabout/structure/gc_1185203480305.shtm
and one here:
http://www.dhs.gov/xoig/
I also was a friendly acquaintance for a couple years with a guy who works for this agency:
https://www.cia.gov/offices-of-cia/intelligence-analysis/organization-1/orea.html
I've talked to a TON of people who work directly for the government. They have shared a great deal with me, but nothing that would lose them their jobs. And, like I said, there are people within the agencies with differing viewpoints on substantive matters. Your father and your visits to him at work have left you with one opinion, my discussions with those working in relevant agencies, in addition to other outlets for gaining knowledge, have left me with a different view.
I have no idea what sort of security clearance your father has, but I'm guessing (hoping?) that the DHS isn't handing out security clearances to every relative, or even all the children, of their employees. You work as a chef, right? I can't see why they would give you such a clearance, as it's unnecessary for your work. (Again, what are you, some kind of Super Spy-Chef?) So, while I can imagine you watching someone in DHS shuffling papers, stringing computer cables, making coffee, or having a low-level, non-secret discussion about something, I highly doubt you saw something terribly secret or something that any current or former DHS employee couldnt' talk to the general public (or the press) about, or anything that couldn't be described in a good article somewhere. Because if a chef who happens to be the kid of an employee can just go in there and see or hear something that substantial, that signficant, then it seems to me that represents a lapse in security of its own. Seymour Hersh, for one example, certainly has a lot of friends on The Inside, too. He's probably
forgotten more straight-from-the-source info. than you've ever seen or heard.
One can know a
great deal about a subject without personally witnessing every detail - and again, I have my doubts that you've witnessed that - or even knowing people in "high places" (as you seem to imply about your father). For example, did you see/hear them actually tapping/listening in on a possible terrorist phone call from outside the U.S. (or otherwise)?? If so, it strikes me as problematic that you were able to do that without clearance.
So, in the future, all of the subjects that come up here on the board in which you have not been inside the relevant government agency buildings, or don't know someone directly involved, or have physically seen them at work with your own eyes, and your knowledge is "merely" second-hand, should your views be dismissed out of hand? I think not, but if that's where you're going with this line of thinking, so be it. I've been in the main HQ for the Dept. of State (well past the zone open to the general public), for example, but I'm not going to say that my views on foreign policy necessarily trump those who haven't been there. That would be silly.
ANYONE can have a completely valid, reasonable, rational, well-informed opinion about security matters without having been inside a secured federal building.