Philosophical Question...

[JohnnyThompson]

There are 6 women:

Women A: Has a boyfriend/fiance/husband with whom she has a monogamous relationship with. Women A loves it when other people watch her have sex. So she has a web cam set up that streams her and her boyfriend/fiance/husband having sex. Since her goal is to get as many viewers as possible, she does not charge to watch her have sex. To make a living, she has a "regular" job that pays her well.

Women B: Is just like Women A in every aspect, EXCEPT she does not have a boyfriend/fiance/husband so she ends up having sex with different men, sometimes they are random strangers (of course without STDs) and sometimes they are friends or acquaintances.

Women C: Has a boyfriend/fiance/husband with whom she has a monogamous relationship with. The two decide to have a professional crew videotape their sex life and they produce it on film, distribute and sell the tapes for a profit. This is the women's only occupation and it pays them well. The women likes having sex on film, but if she could have another job with all other variables (salary, time off work, flexibility, etc.) being constant, she probably would.

Women D: Is just like Women C in every aspect, EXCEPT she does not have a boyfriend/fiance/husband so she ends up having sex with different men, sometimes they are random strangers (of course without STDs) and sometimes they are friends or acquaintances.

Women E: Has a boyfriend/fiance/husband with whom she has a monogamous relationship with. She videotapes their sex life and keeps a collection of it in her home for only her and her boyfriend/fiance/husband's viewing pleasure. To make a living, she has a "regular" job that pays her well.

Women F Is just like Women E in every aspect, EXCEPT she does not have a boyfriend/fiance/husband so she ends up having sex with different men, sometimes they are random strangers (of course without STDs) and sometimes they are friends or acquaintances.

Do you believe that there is a "moral" difference between any of these women? (Remember: If you think pornography is not immoral to begin with, then you answer should be 'NO'.)

 

[skechers]

Aristotle is crying in Valhalla.

 

[RozofGG]

I just think they have different ays to express their sexuality

and I'm not even one of these women ..; though I am definitely a woman!

 

[D-rock]

I don't know about morality, because different people have a different view on what's moral. If I was in a personal relationship I could never let the other person have sex with somebody else while in the relationship. Taping ourselves doing it wouldn't be something I would ever do either, but I wouldn't find it as wrong as either of us having sex with other people. That's just from my personal moral perspective. I don't hold anybody else to my morals if what they do doesn't affect me.

Now as far as things other than morality I think some situations you mentioned might potentially be viewed as more pathetic or sad than others to me. Do the women who have sex with other people, in your example, even like or are attracted to the other person or is it just a plain money grab? An adult performers that set her limits, likes who she works with, truly likes what she does, and is attracted to the other performers she's with is different than my opinion than somebody that will just completely sell themselves out and will do pretty much any (or at least a lot more) acts for money, doesn't like what she's doing, will work with anybody no matter how big of a slimeball or looser that person is as long as the cash flows in, goes through the motions, will regret what she does later on, and would much rather be doing something else if they cold get anywhere near the same amount of money for it.

 

[HeartBroker]

Information overload
Systems shutt...tt...tting do...do...d o w n....

 

[jamrak]

the only moral rule is to be honest

so, to my opinon there is no difference in terms of morals, if all these girls are honest to those with whom they have any type of relations.

having sex with different people, video taping sex, being a porn star, or being a striptease dancer is an action which by itself has no link to the morals.

it is bad, only when there is a place for lies. when there is no lies, everything is ok.

 

[antoniogarcia]

what?

hehe

 

[mrtrebus]

I gave up at woman D. . .

 

[curiousWAN]

so you think woman e and woman f not different?

woman e only videotapes what they ALREADY do. if doing it not wrong, videotaping and watching it with the person you make love should be alright as well.

 

[Bone]

what about Woman G?

 

[Torre82]

I think this involves too many details for an intelligent reply.

Sooo.. I think they all suck for not having sex with me. Off-camera. Hopefully considering me an eligible marriage candidate. Approval is hawt.

 

[Gordar]

(remember: If you think pornography is not immoral to begin with, then you answer should be 'no'.)

'no'.

 

[Gordar]

To the mods: sorry, It took me a bit longer to write this than expected & could no longer edit my last post...


Let me ask you a question.



Which of these guys are immoral according to you?



Guy A has a monogamous relationship and only fucks his gf/wife. He doesn't tape it.

Guy B has a monogamous relationship and only fucks his gf/wife. He does tape it, but his gf/wife knows it.

Guy C has a monogamous relationship and only fucks his gf/wife. He does tape it, but his gf/wife doesn't know it.

Guy D fucks around with everyone, even though he has a gf/wife. She knows it and accepts it. Nothing is being taped.

Guy E fucks around with everyone, even though he has a gf/wife. She doesn't know it. Nothing is being taped.

Guy F fucks around with everyone, even though he has a gf/wife. She knows it and accepts it. His adventures are taped & his gf/wife and other girls know it.

Guy G fucks around with everyone, even though he has a gf/wife. She doesn't know it. His adventures are taped & of course his gf/wife isn't aware of it.

Guy H fucks around with everyone, even though he has a gf/wife. She knows it and accepts it. His adventures are taped & his gf/wife and other girls he fucks don't know it's being taped.

Guy I has no gf/wife and fucks around with everyone. He doesn't tape anything.

Guy J has no gf/wife and fucks around with everyone. He tapes everything but tells the girls in advance.

Guy K has no gf/wife and fucks around with everyone. He tapes everything & doesn't tell the girls.


The immoral people in my opinion are guys C, E, G, H and K. The others are not immoral at all as they are honest towards their partners. The same applies to girls, wether they are pornstars or president candidates or as far as I'm concerned, nuns. Like Jamrak already said, honesty is what's important.